Audience discussion with Paul Watson, subject of ECO-PIRATE: THE PAUL WATSON STORY

Audience members speak with Paul Watson, subject of ECO-PIRATE: THE PAUL WATSON STORY. Photo courtesy of Mary Shea.
by Brian Lepire
Environmental activist Paul Watson has been called a lot of things over his forty year mission to save the world’s oceans. “Pirate”, “hero”, “terrorist”, “inspiration”, “narcissist”, and “star” were some of the terms mentioned in ECO-PIRATE: THE PAUL WATSON STORY, director Trish Dolman’s exploration of Watson’s life from Greenpeace board member to founder of the Sea Shepherd Society and reality TV star.
Using interviews, archival footage, and film shot during one of Watson’s recent missions to stop Japanese whaling ships fishing in the Artic Oceans, Dolman tries to show every side of Watson. The film does not shy away from showing the cruelty Watson is fighting, the controversial tactics he’s used over forty years, and the destruction to his personal life left in the wake.
Watson called Salem Film Fest from his ship via Skype following the film’s March 6th premiere to take audience questions about the film, how individuals can get involved in environmental activism, and his recent successes against the Japanese whaling industry. Below are a few questions Captain Watson answered for the audience that night.
Where are you?
Right now we are in Melbourne, in Victoria, Australia, and we just returned from the Southern Ocean after three months.
Is that a campaign you can tell us about?
We have been chasing the Japanese whaling fleet over 17000 miles over the last three months. They haven’t killed many whales, so they are on their way [back] out there now. The BOB BARKER (one of the Sea Shepherd’s three largest vessels) encountered them again two days ago and they left. I don’t anticipate they filled more than 25% of their quota. Editor’s note: CNN.com reported March 9th the Japanese whaling fleet filled less than 30% of their quota, catching 266 minke whales and 1 fin whale.
I understand director Trish Dolman and her crew were on board with you for two-three months?
Yes, she was with us on our campaigns in the Galapagos Island and our 2005-06 campaigns to the Southern Ocean, which ended up leaving Australia and going to South Africa. That was our second campaign to Antarctica. We’ve done eight [campaigns] all together.
A lot has changed over those years. We’ve gotten more support that has translated into more resources and we’ve become more effective. Last year, we went down with more resources than the Japanese whaling fleet. They only took 17% of their quota and left early.
What do I need to do personally so that, when I’m your age, there are still whales and dolphins and seals and sharks in the ocean?
I think we have to understand that we can’t depend on governments or large organizations to solve the problems. All change comes through the passion, courage, imagination, initiative of individuals. We all have to understand that we have the power to change the world.
How do you deal or help people deal with the inevitable feelings of doubt that can creep in when we, sometimes, face the fact that things seem so helpless or overwhelming?
Back in 1973, I had the opportunity to work with the American Indian Movement and [helped] during the occupation of Wounded Knee. I was a medic during that, and I learned many things from the Plains Indians. One of them was you don’t do what you do worrying if you’re going to win or lose. You do what you do because it’s the right thing to do, the only thing to do, and you focus on that. Don’t worry about if in the end you are going to overcome your enemy. Just focus on the present. That’s what we do, and it’s amazing how many things we can be successful at just doing that.
I’m not a pessimist. I don’t get worried that we’re going to fail or anything like that. I don’t focus on that. I’ve found, over the years, the thing that works is persistence and patience. We’ve never backed down from a campaign. We always carry our campaigns on to fruition and we usually win…You just have to stick in with it.
Do you plan on buying any more ships?
We intend to return to the Southern Ocean at the end of this year with four vessels. The STEVE IRWIN, BOB BARKER, BRIGITTE BARDOT were the three vessels in our fleet this year. We were handicapped this year because the BRIGITTE BARDOT was handicapped by a rogue wave. Without that scout vessel, we weren’t able to close in on [the Japanese whaling fleet], although we could keep them running. I need two scout vessels. We’re working on getting that fourth vessel this year. We also have two helicopters, and will also be adding more than the one drone we have right now. We actually should have more vessels than the Japanese whaling fleet or just as many next year.
In the meantime, we’ll be taking the BRIGITTE BARDOT to the South Pacific to protect sharks. We have an on-going campaign in the Galápagos’ working with the rangers there to stop poaching. We’ve also cut the poaching of dolphins over the last two years. We’re also battling the Bluefin tuna poachers in the Mediterranean Sea…We have an awful lot of these campaigns, so these resources are very important to us.
When did you get a chance to see the film, and do you think it really is the story of Paul Watson?
I always have a hard time with that question because whenever anyone makes a film about – like, if it’s a biographical film – it’s a little difficult to watch. I leave it to the audience to decide whether it’s a good film or not. I’m really not in a position to view it objectively. If people like it, then I’m happy for that. When they make films about you, they tend to be a little personal; it is difficult to deal with.
Can you tell us a little bit about the difference between having a documentary film crew and dealing with that production over 8 to 9 years, versus the TV crew you’ve been dealing with on “Whale Wars”?
Well, with the documentary crew, you have a small film crew and they come with you, then they go away, then they come back again. With our television crew, they’re their 24-7 every day. The Animal Planet [network] crew is a total of 16 [people] on our two vessels. But after a few days, everyone gets used to having a camera in their face and microphones on. Almost too used to it, actually. Sometimes people forget they are there. I think our crew has certainly gotten good at dealing with the camera crews. We recognize – and always have recognized – that the most powerful weapon in the world is the camera and we should take advantage of that.
Were you surprised by any of the story lines that came out in either medium?
No. I’ve always made it clear that any documentary crews are there to observe and report as they see it. Not as we would like them to see it, but as they see it. I really feel that’s important to do – to allow people, whether they are making a documentary or a TV show, to allow them free access to interrupt it the way they see it. The way I look at things and the way the general public look at things of course are going to be different. I have a particular bias, and that bias shouldn’t be in control of the film. It should have that objective outlook.











